Food and Beverage Menu
Menu subject to change based on product seasonality and availability.
Sunday–Monday: noon–midnight
Tuesday–Thursday: noon–12:30 a.m.
Friday–Saturday: noon–1:00 a.m.
(GF) Gluten-free, (DF) Dairy Free, (NF) Nut Free, (V) Vegan, (VG) Vegetarian
All our meats are sourced from sustainable farms, and all fish and seafood products are either sustainable, line, or wild-caught.
*Consuming raw or uncooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.
8.875% NY Tax will be added to the charge
Shared Plates
All prices listed are in USD.
Kaviari Caviar Oscietre Prestige, MP
Buckwheat Blinis, Lemon Crème Fraiche, Traditional Condiments
50gr
Kaviari Caviar Oscietre Gold, MP
Buckwheat Blinis, Lemon Crème Fraiche, Traditional Condiments
50gr
Half Dozen East Beach Blonde Oysters (GF, DF, NF)
Ginger-Sake Mignonette
36
Tuna Ceviche (GF, DF, NF)
Jalapeño, Avocado, Chipotle Crema, Tortilla Chips
36
Prime Aged Beef Sliders (NF)
Onion Marmalade, Raclette Cheese, Green Peppercorn Aioli
34
Homemade Pigs in a Blanket (NF)
Spicy Brown Mustard, Andouille Sausage
23
Bemelmans Chicken Wings
Brown Sugar Chili Glaze, Black Garlic Ranch
22
Charcuterie and Cheese Board
Chef Selection, Olives, Pickled Vegetables, Almonds
42
Farmer’s Market Crudité
Coconut Yogurt Tzatziki
26
Fried Olives
Lemon Vodka Aioli
26
Shrimp Cocktail (GF, NF, DF)
Brandy Cocktail Sauce, Lemon
31
Steak Tartare
Hand-Cut Filet Mignon, Potato Chips
36
Behelman's Favorites
All prices listed are in USD.
Baby Romaine Salad (NF)
Soft Boiled Egg, Sourdough Croutons, Parmesan, Preserved Lemon, White Anchovies, Caesar Dressing
32
House-Made Smoked Salmon (NF)
Dill, Boursin, Lemon Vinaigrette, Rye Toast
30
Chicken BLT (NF)
Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Ciabatta, Lemon-Basil Mayonnaise
35
Connecticut Lobster Roll (NF)
Poached Maine Lobster, Warm Butter, Chives, Crispy Shallots
47
Carlyle Burger (NF)
Artisanal Brioche Bun, Special Sauce, Cheddar
38
Steak Frites (GF, NF)
Prime NY Strip, Fries, Truffle Hollandaise
63
Sides
All prices listed are in USD.
French Fries
16
Truffle Fries
18
Brussels Sprouts
16
Mac & Cheese
16
Desserts
All prices listed are in USD.
NY Cheesecake (NF)
Lemon Cream, Pistachio
24
Key Lime Pie
Blueberry Compote
24
Flourless Chocolate Torte (NF, GF)
Crème Chantilly, Sour Cherry Compote
24
Martinis
All prices listed are in USD.
Madeline’s Vesper
Bombay Sapphire Gin, Grey Goose Vodka, Cocchi Americano Vermouth
28
Madeline’s Vesper No. 2
Hard Cut Vodka, Jacoulot Le Petit Brandy, Abricot du Roussillon Liqueur, Dolin Blanc Vermouth, Saffron Tincture
28
The Carlyle Whisper
Artingstall Gin, Lustau Fino Sherry, Italicus Rosolio di Bergamotto, Orange Bitters
32
The Gibson
Procera Blue Dot Gin, Cocchi Americano Vermouth, The Japanese Umami Bitters*, Pearl Onions, Nori Dust
42
Mezcalini
Ilegal Reposado Mezcal, Mancino Secco, Rockey’s Botanical Liqueur, Angostura Bitters
30
Elaine’s Smokeshow
Farmers Gin, Lagavulin 16yr Single Malt Scotch Whisky, Mancino Secco, Smoked Olive Brine
37
Room 34XX
No. 3 London Dry Gin, Dolin Blanc Vermouth, Ume Plum Liqueur, Moët & Chandon Essence
36
Bemelmans Confidential
Fords Gin Infused with Cucumber, Dolin Blanc Vermouth, Yellow Chartreuse, Tarragon Oil
32
The Big Apple
Neversink Gin Infused with Sage, Neversink Apple Aperitif, Busnel Calvados, Dolin Dry Vermouth, P.X. Sherry, Acid-Adjusted Apple Juice, Orange Bitters, Moët & Chandon Essence
38
1947
Harridan Vodka, Jacoulot Le Petit Brandy, Mancino Secco, Banane du Brésil Liqueur, Black Walnut Bitters
37
The Ramble
Revivalist Gin, Peach Wine Vermouth, Lavender Honey Syrup, Peychaud’s Bitters
32
Manhattanhenge
Ki No Tea Kyoto Dry Gin, Genmaicha-Infused Blanc Vermouth, Yuzu Liqueur, Nigori Sake, The Japanese Umami Bitters, Saline Solution
36
Signature Cocktails
All prices listed are in USD.
Bobby’s Manhattan
Santa Teresa 1796 Rum, Carpano Antica, Cherry Heering, Scrappy’s Orange Bitters, Angostura Bitters, Dry Gypsophila
32
JFK Daiquiri
Mount Gay XO Rum, The Bitter Truth Golden Falernum Liqueur, Lime Juice, Simple Syrup
28
Jackie O
X-Rated Passion Fruit–Infused Vodka, Grey Goose, Lime Juice, Champagne Float, Fresh Thyme
30
The Corner Booth
Michter’s Rye, Carmes de Rieussec – Sauternes 2018, Mancino Chinato Vermouth, Barbadillo Manzanilla Sherry, Bénédictine Liqueur, Orange Bitters, Mole Bitters, Saline Solution
35
The Serrano
Casamigos Añejo, Grand Marnier, St-Germain, Egg White, Homemade Rosemary & Ginger Syrup, Peychaud’s Aromatic Bitters, Mojito Mix, Top-Up Moët & Chandon
32
Old Cuban
Bacardi 8, Fresh Lime Juice, Simple Syrup, Angostura, Top-Up Moët & Chandon
28
The Summer Wind Café
Casa Del Sol Reposado, Mr. Black Coffee Liqueur, Frangelico Hazelnut Liqueur, Espresso Coffee, Mole Bitters
36
G&T and Low ABV Selection
All prices listed are in USD.
Mr. Carlyle
Tanqueray No. 10 Gin, St-Germain Elderflower Liqueur, Badger Tonic Water, Lemon Juice
30
The Dutch Sling Spritz
Old Duff Genever, Cocchi Americano, Bénédictine, Lemon Juice, Peychaud’s Bitters, Top-Up with Badger Blood Orange Soda
30
The White Jacket
Ono Sake, Italicus Rosolio di Bergamotto, Verjus Blanc, Tio Pepe Fino Sherry, Orange Blossom, Top-Up with Badger Blood Orange Soda
32
The Artist’s Cobbler
Cincoro Reposado Tequila, P.X. Sherry, White Port, Rooibos & Fig Syrup, Lemon Juice, Black Walnut Bitters
34
Zero-Proof Cocktails
All prices listed are in USD.
Pepito “The Bad Hat”
Ritual “Tequila-Alternative”, Lime Juice, Homemade Orange Syrup, Badger Club Soda
28
Miss Clavel
Orange Juice, Cranberry Juice, Pineapple Juice, Lime Juice, Grenadine, Rosemary Ginger Syrup
22
Film Noir
Rasasvada Black Ginger, Top-Up with Ginger Beer
32
Secret Garden
Fresh Sage, Fresh Mint, Fresh Ginger, NY State Wildflowers Honey, Fresh Lemon Juice
22