Food and Beverage Menu
Menu subject to change based on product seasonality and availability.
Sunday–Monday: 12 p.m. – 12 a.m.
Tuesday–Thursday: 12 p.m. – 12:30 a.m.
Friday–Saturday: 12 p.m. – 1 a.m.
(GF) Gluten-free, (DF) Dairy Free, (NF) Nut Free, (V) Vegan, (VG) Vegetarian
All our meats are sourced from sustainable farms, and all fish and seafood products are either sustainable, line, or wild-caught.
*Consuming raw or uncooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.
8.875% NY Tax will be added to the charge
Shared Plates
All prices listed are in USD.
Kaviari Caviar Osciètre Prestige, 50g (NF)
Egg Yolk | Egg White | Red Onion | Chives | Lemon Crème Fraîche | Bugles | Toast Points | Buckwheat Blinis
305
Kaviari Caviar Oscietre Gold, 50g (NF)
Egg Yolk | Egg White | Red Onion | Chives | Lemon Crème Fraîche | Bugles | Toast Points | Buckwheat Blinis
435
Half Dozen Blue Point Oysters (GF, DF, NF)
Seasonal Mignonette | Brandy Cocktail Sauce
43
Prime Aged Beef Sliders (NF)
Onion Marmalade | Cheddar Cheese | Green Peppercorn Aioli
34
House-Made Pigs in a Blanket (NF)
Brown Mustard | Spicy Andouille Sausage
29
Zesty Beer Batter Onion Rings (VG, NF)
Mango Barbeque Sauce
23
Charcuterie & Cheese Board
Chef's Selection of Two Cured Meats & Two Cheeses | Olives | Almonds | Seasonal Mostarda | Crackers
61
Shrimp Cocktail (GF, NF, DF)
Brandy Cocktail Sauce | Lemon
38
Steak Tartare (GF, NF, DF)
Hand-Cut Filet Mignon | Potato Chips
63
Caviar Nibbles (NF)
Organic Egg Yolk | Crème Fraîche | Chives | Potato Pavé
51
Bemelmans Favorites
All prices listed are in USD.
Baby Romaine Salad (NF)
Soft Boiled Egg | Sourdough Croutons | Parmesan | Preserved Lemon | White Anchovies | Caesar Dressing
33
House-Cured Smoked Salmon (NF)
Dill | Boursin | Lemon Vinaigrette | Rye Toast
45
Carlyle Burger (NF)
Baby Romaine | Cheddar | Red Onion | Special Sauce | Brioche
39
Crab Cake Sandwich (NF)
Jonah Crab | Panko | Brioche Bun | Remoulade | Lettuce | Pickles
49
Chicken BLT (NF)
Ciabatta | Lemon-Basil Mayonnaise
36
Turkey Club (DF, NF)
Baby Romaine | Fried Egg | Bacon | Tomato | Black Garlic Aioli
36
Pastrami Sandwich (NF)
Spicy Coleslaw | Swiss Cheese | Pickles | Rye Toast
38
Steak Frites (NF)
Prime NY Strip 8oz | Sauce au Poivre
63
Sides
All prices listed are in USD.
French Fries (NF, VG)
18
Truffle Fries (NF, VG)
26
Desserts
All prices listed are in USD.
NY Cheesecake (NF)
Mixed Berries | Sour Cream
24
Cookie Plate (V, NF)
Double Chocolate Chip & Vanilla Funfetti
24
Martinis
All prices listed are in USD.
Madeline’s Vesper
Bombay Sapphire Gin | Grey Goose Vodka | Cocchi Americano
32
Ludwig's Brush
Hard Cut Vodka | Jacoulot le Petit Brandy | Abricot du Roussillon Liqueur | Dolin Blanc Vermouth | Saffron Tincture
33
The Gibson
Procera Blue Dot Gin | Cocchi Vermouth di Torino Extra Dry | The Japanese Umami Bitters* | Pearl Onions | Nori Dust
*Contains Fish & Mushrooms
43
Bemelmans Confidential
Cucumber Infused No.3 London Dry Gin | Dolin Blanc Vermouth | Yellow Chartreuse Liqueur | Tarragon Oil
34
Mezcalini
Los Siete Misterios Doba-Yej Mezcal | Rockey’s Botanical Liqueur | Cocchi Vermouth di Torino Extra Dry | Angostura Bitters
31
The Paul F(e)ig Martini
Artingstall's Gin | Cocchi Extra Dry Vermouth di Torino | Sykophilos Fig Liqueur | Shiso Bitters
32
Signature Cocktails
All prices listed are in USD.
La Vie En Red
Leyenda 1925 Tequila Reposado | Campari | Crème de Fraise des Bois | Gonzalez Byass La Copa Rojo Vermouth | Tio Pepe Fino Sherry
38
Mr. Carlyle
Bluecoat American Dry Gin | St-Germain Elderflower Liqueur | Badger Tonic Water
30
On the Rocks
Compass Box Orchard House Blended Malt Scotch | Butterscotch | Tio Pepe Fino Sherry | Lustau Pedro Ximénez Cordial
32
Jane's Daisy
Widow Jane Straight Bourbon 10YR | Heimat White Peach Liqueur | Yuzu | Angostura Bitters
32
Bobby's Manhattan
Santa Teresa 1796 Rum | Carpano Antica Formula | Cherry Heering Liqueur | Orange Bitters | Angostura Bitters
34
Old Cuban
Bacardi Reserva Ocho Rum | Lime Juice | Simple Syrup | Fresh Mint | Angostura Bitters | Top-Up Moët & Chandon Champagne
31
Jackie O
Grey Goose Vodka | X-Rated Passion Fruit Infused Vodka | Lime Juice | Top-Up Moët & Chandon Champagne
35
JFK Daiquiri
Mount Gay XO Rum | The Bitter Truth Golden Falernum Liqueur | Lime Juice | Lime Cordial | Simple Syrup
30
The Serrano
Casamigos Añejo | Grand Marnier | St-Germain Elderflower Liqueur | Egg White | House-Made Rosemary & Ginger Syrup | Peychaud Aromatic Bitters | Mojito Mix | Top-Up Moët & Chandon Champagne
33
Zero-Proof Cocktails
All prices listed are in USD.
Pepito “The Bad Hat”
Ritual “Tequila-Alternative” | Lime Juice | Blood Orange Oleo | Badger Club Soda
28
Two Straight Lines
Roots Divino Bianco Non-Alcoholic Vermouth | Ritual Gin Alternative | Verjus Blanc | El Guapo Cucumber Lavender Bitters
26
Ginger Highball
Lime Juice | Verjus Blanc | Saline Solution | Lemon-Thyme Foam | Badger Ginger Beer
26